How to Replace the Fuel Cap on a 2019 Subaru Forester
Step-by-step DIY guide with safety tips, required part, EVAP check engine light notes, and cost savings
How to Replace the Fuel Cap on a 2019 Subaru Forester
Step-by-step DIY guide with safety tips, required part, EVAP check engine light notes, and cost savings
🔧 Forester - Fuel Cap Replacement
Replacing the fuel cap on your Forester is a very simple repair. The fuel cap seals the fuel tank system, and a worn or loose cap can cause fuel smell, vapor leaks, or a check engine light related to the EVAP system.
Difficulty Level: Beginner | Estimated Time: 5-10 minutes
⚠️ Safety & Precautions
- 🔥 Do not smoke or work near open flames while the fuel door is open.
- 🧯 Avoid using power tools near the fuel filler area.
- 🌬️ Work in a well-ventilated area because fuel vapors can be present.
- 🚗 Make sure your Forester is parked, turned off, and the parking brake is set.
- 🔋 Battery disconnect is not required for this repair.
🔧 Required Tools
You'll need the following tools for this repair:
- Safety glasses
- Nitrile gloves
🔩 Required Parts
HowToo sells all the parts you need for this repair:
- Fuel filler cap - Qty: 1
📋 Before You Begin
- 🅿️ Park your Forester on level ground and set the parking brake.
- 🔑 Turn the ignition off and keep the key away from the start button area.
- ⛽ If the check engine light is on because of the old fuel cap, it may take several drive cycles to clear after replacement.
- 📌 A drive cycle means the vehicle is driven and parked normally enough times for the engine computer to recheck the fuel vapor system.
🔨 Step-by-Step Instructions
Follow these steps in order:
Step 1: Open the Fuel Door
- Use your hand to press the rear edge of the fuel door inward, then release it so it pops open.
- Put on safety glasses and nitrile gloves before touching the fuel cap area.
- Work slowly near fuel vapors.
Step 2: Remove the Old Fuel Cap
- Use your hand to turn the old fuel filler cap counterclockwise until it comes loose.
- Let the cap hang by its tether if it is still attached.
- The tether is the small plastic strap that keeps the cap connected to the fuel door area.
Step 3: Detach the Cap Tether
- Use your hand to unclip the old cap tether from the fuel door or filler area.
- Do not pull hard on the fuel door. The fuel door hinge can bend if forced.
- If the tether clip feels stuck, wiggle it gently by hand until it releases.
Step 4: Install the New Fuel Cap Tether
- Use your hand to attach the new fuel cap tether to the same mounting point where the old one was attached.
- Make sure the tether is not twisted or pinched.
- A straight tether lasts longer.
Step 5: Install the New Fuel Cap
- Use your hand to place the new fuel filler cap onto the fuel filler neck.
- Turn the cap clockwise until it clicks.
- Subaru-style fuel caps should be tightened until you hear at least one clear click.
- No torque spec is used for this cap; tighten by hand only.
Step 6: Close the Fuel Door
- Use your hand to close the fuel door until it sits flush with the body.
- Check that the cap tether is fully inside and not caught in the fuel door.
✅ After Repair
- ✅ Start your Forester and confirm there is no fuel smell around the fuel door.
- 🔍 If the check engine light was on, drive normally for a few days. The EVAP system may need several trips to retest itself.
- 🧰 If a scan tool is available, you may clear EVAP-related codes after installing the new cap.
- ⚠️ If the check engine light returns, the issue may be elsewhere in the EVAP system, such as a purge valve, vent valve, or vapor leak.
💰 DIY vs Shop Cost
Shop Cost: $40-$90 parts + labor
DIY Cost: $15-$35 parts only
You Save: $25-$55 by doing it yourself!
Shop labor rates vary but typically run $100-$150/hour. This repair takes a shop approximately 0.2-0.3 hours.
🎯 Ready to get started?
HowToo makes it easy: same-day/2-day shipping on every part, plus all the tools and specialty tools you need! Check out the parts and tools sections below to add everything to your cart.








