How to Replace the Fuel Cap on a 2016 Subaru Legacy (Fix EVAP/Check Engine Light)
Step-by-step replacement with tools, OEM-style part tips, sealing-surface checks, and safety precautions for 1990, 1991, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996, 1997, 1998, 1999
How to Replace the Fuel Cap on a 2016 Subaru Legacy (Fix EVAP/Check Engine Light)
Step-by-step replacement with tools, OEM-style part tips, sealing-surface checks, and safety precautions for 1990, 1991, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996, 1997, 1998, 1999
🔧 Legacy - Fuel Cap Replacement
Replacing the fuel cap on your Legacy is a quick job that helps prevent fuel vapors from leaking out and can stop an “EVAP” or “Check Engine” light caused by a loose or failed cap seal.
You’ll remove the old cap, check the filler neck sealing surface, and install the new cap until it clicks tight.
Difficulty Level: Beginner | Estimated Time: 0.1-0.2 hours
⚠️ Safety & Precautions
- ⚠️ Work outside or in a well-ventilated area; fuel vapors are flammable.
- ⚠️ No smoking, flames, or hot work nearby.
- ⚠️ Do not replace the cap with the engine running.
- ⚠️ Battery disconnect is not required for this repair.
🔧 Required Tools
You'll need the following tools for this repair:
- Nitrile gloves
- Shop towel
- Flashlight
🔩 Required Parts
HowToo sells all the parts you need for this repair:
- Fuel cap (OEM-style, tethered) - Qty: 1
📋 Before You Begin
- Park on level ground and shift to Park.
- Turn the ignition OFF and remove the key/fob from the cabin area.
- Let the area cool if you just drove (avoid working around hot exhaust).
🔨 Step-by-Step Instructions
Follow these steps in order:
Step 1: Open the fuel door
- Use your hand to open the fuel door on the driver-side rear quarter panel.
- Use a flashlight to look for dirt around the filler area.
Step 2: Remove the old fuel cap
- Put on nitrile gloves.
- Turn the cap counterclockwise by hand until it releases.
- Let the cap hang by the tether (the small retaining strap that keeps you from dropping it).
Step 3: Clean and inspect the sealing surfaces
- Use a shop towel to wipe the filler neck lip (where the cap’s rubber seal sits).
- Check the old cap’s rubber seal for cracks, flattening, or missing pieces.
- Clean, dry sealing surfaces prevent EVAP leaks.
Step 4: Install the new fuel cap
- Place the new cap on the filler neck and turn it clockwise by hand.
- Tighten until you hear/feel at least one click (this is the cap’s built-in limiter so it doesn’t get overtightened).
- If it doesn’t click, remove it and try again to ensure the threads started correctly.
Step 5: Close the fuel door
- Close the fuel door firmly by hand until it latches.
- Use the flashlight for a quick final look to ensure the cap sits flush.
✅ After Repair
- Start the engine and confirm there’s no fuel smell around the filler area.
- If you were replacing the cap due to a Check Engine light, it may take a few normal drive cycles for the light to turn off (or you can clear codes with a scan tool).
- Recheck the cap after your next fill-up: tighten until it clicks.
💰 DIY vs Shop Cost
Shop Cost: $40-$120 (parts + labor)
DIY Cost: $15-$45 (parts only)
You Save: $25-$75 by doing it yourself!
Shop labor rates vary but typically run $100-$150/hour. This repair takes a shop approximately 0.1-0.2 hours.
🎯 Ready to get started?
HowToo makes it easy: same-day/2-day shipping on every part, plus all the tools and specialty tools you need! Check out the parts and tools sections below to add everything to your cart.









