Howtoo Logo
2016 Subaru Legacy
1990 - 1999 Subaru Legacy
Flat 4 2.2L
Compatible with more variants.
Bryan specialist avatar

Have a Question? Ask a Specialist

Here is everything needed for this repair

See what I can do

Make Money

With HowToo

OnOff

Here is just the beginning of what I can do!

Select one to see me in action

Vehicle Features

Image Vehicle Features

ā€œHow do I connect my phone to my stereo?ā€

Vehicle Information

Image Vehicle Information

ā€œWhat is my horsepower and torqueā€

Image Recognition

Image Image Recognition

ā€œWhat is this warning light on my dash?ā€

Troubleshooting

Image Troubleshooting

ā€œI have a P0300 engine codeā€

Vehicle Recognition

Image Vehicle Recognition

ā€œWhat vehicle is this?ā€

Find shops near you

Image Find shops near you

ā€œFind a shop to do this repairā€

Vehicle Talk

Image Vehicle Talk

ā€œWhat’s your favorite vehicle of all time?ā€

  • Guides
  • /
  • Subaru Legacy
  • /
  • 1990 to 1999
  • /
  • How to Replace the Fuel Cap on a 1990-2019 Subaru Legacy (Fix EVAP/Check Engine Light) (Engine: Flat 4 2.5L)
How to Change || Gas Cap

How to Change || Gas Cap

Suggested Parts

See all parts background
See All Parts

Tools & Fluids

Nitrile
Nitrile
Gloves
Paper Towels
Paper Towels
Flashlight
Flashlight
See all parts background
See All Tools

How to Replace the Fuel Cap on a 1990-2019 Subaru Legacy (Fix EVAP/Check Engine Light) (Engine: Flat 4 2.5L)

Step-by-step replacement with tools, OEM-style part tips, sealing-surface checks, and safety precautions

How to Replace the Fuel Cap on a 1990-2019 Subaru Legacy (Fix EVAP/Check Engine Light) (Engine: Flat 4 2.5L)

Step-by-step replacement with tools, OEM-style part tips, sealing-surface checks, and safety precautions for 1990, 1991, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996, 1997, 1998, 1999

Orion
Orion

šŸ”§ Legacy - Fuel Cap Replacement

Replacing the fuel cap on your Legacy is a quick job that helps prevent fuel vapors from leaking out and can stop an ā€œEVAPā€ or ā€œCheck Engineā€ light caused by a loose or failed cap seal.

You’ll remove the old cap, check the filler neck sealing surface, and install the new cap until it clicks tight.

Difficulty Level: Beginner | Estimated Time: 0.1-0.2 hours


āš ļø Safety & Precautions

  • āš ļø Work outside or in a well-ventilated area; fuel vapors are flammable.
  • āš ļø No smoking, flames, or hot work nearby.
  • āš ļø Do not replace the cap with the engine running.
  • āš ļø Battery disconnect is not required for this repair.

šŸ”§ Required Tools

You'll need the following tools for this repair:

  • Nitrile gloves
  • Shop towel
  • Flashlight

šŸ”© Required Parts

HowToo sells all the parts you need for this repair:

  • Fuel cap (OEM-style, tethered) - Qty: 1

šŸ“‹ Before You Begin

  • Park on level ground and shift to Park.
  • Turn the ignition OFF and remove the key/fob from the cabin area.
  • Let the area cool if you just drove (avoid working around hot exhaust).

šŸ”Ø Step-by-Step Instructions

Follow these steps in order:

Step 1: Open the fuel door

  • Use your hand to open the fuel door on the driver-side rear quarter panel.
  • Use a flashlight to look for dirt around the filler area.

Step 2: Remove the old fuel cap

  • Put on nitrile gloves.
  • Turn the cap counterclockwise by hand until it releases.
  • Let the cap hang by the tether (the small retaining strap that keeps you from dropping it).

Step 3: Clean and inspect the sealing surfaces

  • Use a shop towel to wipe the filler neck lip (where the cap’s rubber seal sits).
  • Check the old cap’s rubber seal for cracks, flattening, or missing pieces.
  • Clean, dry sealing surfaces prevent EVAP leaks.

Step 4: Install the new fuel cap

  • Place the new cap on the filler neck and turn it clockwise by hand.
  • Tighten until you hear/feel at least one click (this is the cap’s built-in limiter so it doesn’t get overtightened).
  • If it doesn’t click, remove it and try again to ensure the threads started correctly.

Step 5: Close the fuel door

  • Close the fuel door firmly by hand until it latches.
  • Use the flashlight for a quick final look to ensure the cap sits flush.

āœ… After Repair

  • Start the engine and confirm there’s no fuel smell around the filler area.
  • If you were replacing the cap due to a Check Engine light, it may take a few normal drive cycles for the light to turn off (or you can clear codes with a scan tool).
  • Recheck the cap after your next fill-up: tighten until it clicks.

šŸ’° DIY vs Shop Cost

Shop Cost: $40-$120 (parts + labor)

DIY Cost: $15-$45 (parts only)

You Save: $25-$75 by doing it yourself!

Shop labor rates vary but typically run $100-$150/hour. This repair takes a shop approximately 0.1-0.2 hours.


šŸŽÆ Ready to get started?

HowToo makes it easy: same-day/2-day shipping on every part, plus all the tools and specialty tools you need! Check out the parts and tools sections below to add everything to your cart.

Guide for Fuel Tank Cap replace for these Subaru vehicles

Year Make ModelSub ModelEngineBody Style
2019 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
2019 Subaru Legacy-Flat 6 3.6L-
2018 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
2018 Subaru Legacy-Flat 6 3.6L-
2017 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
2017 Subaru Legacy-Flat 6 3.6L-
2016 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
2016 Subaru Legacy-Flat 6 3.6L-
2015 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
2015 Subaru Legacy-Flat 6 3.6L-
2014 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
2014 Subaru Legacy-Flat 6 3.6L-
2013 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
2013 Subaru Legacy-Flat 6 3.6L-
2012 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
2012 Subaru Legacy-Flat 6 3.6L-
2011 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
2011 Subaru Legacy-Flat 6 3.6L-
2010 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
2010 Subaru Legacy-Flat 6 3.6L-
2004 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
2003 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
2002 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
2001 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
2000 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
1999 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.2L-
1999 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
1998 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.2L-
1998 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
1997 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.2L-
1997 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
1996 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.2L-
1996 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.5L-
1995 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.2L-
1994 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.2L-
1993 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.2L-
1992 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.2L-
1991 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.2L-
1990 Subaru Legacy-Flat 4 2.2L-
Parts
Tools
2016 Subaru Legacy
Menu
Videos
Earn